Monday, 29 October 2018

Thinking about the state of the world.

I haven't blogged in a long time. Over 18 months in fact since my last blog post. I've been thinking about some things lately, and generally when I think about things and I can't get them out of my head, writing them down tends to help.

What I've been thinking about is the world we live in. The political climate mainly. I was sick over the weekend and with no energy to do anything else, I finally started to watch The Handmaid's Tale. I know, I know, I'm late to the party. I also haven't read the book yet so don't stone me. It's on my list and I bought my own copy of the book from Readings probably over a year ago now with very good intentions. I watched Season 1 in a little over a day. When I woke up on Sunday morning, I checked my phone (another bad habit, yes, I'm a terrible person obviously) and saw that a friend had posted "Thinking of Pittsburgh" or something to that effect. I didn't even have to google it because after scrolling for about 2 seconds I found out what had happened. 

So imagine that. I'd been watching a dystopian TV series literally the day before. A world where people are publicly hanged for being different. And I wake up to find that 11 Jews had been murdered in their synagogue on Shabbat. 

On Friday, half of my Year 11 RE (Religious Education) class had finished giving their presentations about some impressive people from history who fought for freedoms and fought for good. People like Nelson Mandela, Eleanor Roosevelt, Martin Luther King Jr, Gandhi. A common theme that came up was non-violent protest and forgiving the oppressors and this made me think of the Humans of New York thread I had been reading the previous day about the genocide in Rwanda. I shared the photos and stories with them and they culminated in this post from one of the politicians talking about reconciliation. The girls were in shock that something like this could happen so recently, even after the Holocaust. Some of them were visibly upset by this and I said that it was not a bad thing they were upset by the stories because it meant they still cared and I implored them to not stand by when they see bad things happening. To not be the bystander who is complicit by their silence.


On Sunday evening I was reading more and more articles about the rise in anti-semitism in the United States over the past 2 years. We know that more and more Far Right governments have been elected internationally, the most recent being in Brazil. And more and more, I worry that the dystopian future, or a return to the past is not far off.


I sincerely hope that the world of Gilead is a long way off, and that I will maintain my rights over my body for a long time to come. But my worries for my people and other minorities who are perceived to be 'the other' even in this day and age are not so easily brushed off.


Just this Friday night, at a Shabbat dinner event, I was trying to explain to someone why I didn't feel entirely comfortable wearing a Magen David necklace in public, but I feel okay to wear my chamsa with 'chai' in the middle of it. The closest I could get was saying that the Magen David is easily identifiable as the symbol of the Jewish people, but the chamsa with chai (meaning 'life') is more spiritual and perhaps only easily identifiable to those 'in the know'. The sad reality is, there are many who still don't trust Jews, and I had an example of that just this evening. I find it so disheartening that this is the case, and more so the fact that she followed it up with "Don't worry, I lived in Caulfield" like that excuses it. To be honest, I'm ashamed that I didn't call her out directly for her comments which verged on anti-semitic. 


I realise that this might just be a collection of thoughts, but for any of my non-Jewish friends (or people who aren't my friends at all and who just stumbled upon this) who are reading this, start a conversation with your Jewish friends about the shooting. Ask them how they feel about it and whether they're okay. If you don't feel comfortable to do that, that's okay. But the worst anti-semitic crime in US history happened this weekend. 11 Jews were killed just for being Jewish and for the fact that their synagogue supported other minorities and refugees. And a lot of Jews worldwide are reeling from this horrific event. And maybe some, like me, are worried that something similar could happen here, or in another city to people I know and love. Being conscious of that is a start. 


The Handmaid's Tale, and the shooting, and so much else led me to these thoughts. This poem hasn't been far from my thoughts either.






As the Rwandan man in the Humans of New York story said, "Consider the ways that we are a single tribe." 


יהיה זכרם לברכה

Monday, 24 April 2017

Never again. Lest we forget

Yesterday was Yom Hashoa (Holocaust Memorial Day). Today is Anzac Day. 

I've been thinking about a lot of things lately to do with my culture and identity and Australia's culture and identity. One of the reasons could be because I'm just an introspective person and think about my place in the world. But one of the other reasons is thanks to the new citizenship test based on our 'values' that Malcolm Turnbull announced last week. I am struggling to reconcile the fact that in one breath he is declaring that Australia has a very proud multicultural history and we are one of the most successful multicultural nations on earth, but then he follows that with a statement that we need to defend Australia's values and put Australians first.

I remember when I was preparing to go to Belgium for my Rotary Exchange and we were given a book by the Rotarians called the Little Aussie Fact Book (or something like that). It was for us (the outgoing exchange students) to take away with us to help us be ambassadors for our country and to educate our host countries about where we came from. One of the facts that astounded me was that at the time (in 2000) a quarter of all Australians were born overseas. More astonishing than that was the fact that something like 50% were descendants of immigrant parents. The figures haven't changed that much since then. 

I have always been incredibly proud to be an Australian citizen. I only have one passport, I only have one citizenship, despite having been born in South Africa. When I played 'two truths and a lie' on hikes with the girls at Howqua one of my truths was that I have lived in five countries. But Australia is always home. I'd see the Qantas planes when I was at airports overseas and feel a buzz. When I hear I Still Call Australia Home and You're the Voice I still get teary. But lately, I've not been feeling so proud to be Australian. 

In June 1938 at the Evian Conference, Australia's delegate refused the increase Australia's intake of Jewish refugees from Europe who were attempting to flee the Nazis and said the following: "as we have no real racial problem, we are not desirous of importing one by encouraging any scheme of large-scale foreign migration". I remember reading these words for the first time when I visited Yad Vashem in 2005 and I lost it. For those who haven't visited Yad Vashem, it appears at the start of the museum and I just remember thinking, 'if only they had opened their doors, so much of this could have been avoided.' So many turned their backs on the Jews in World War 2. So many refused to help and said it wasn't their problem. So many became complicit in the horrors of the Holocaust by simply turning a blind eye and not speaking up.

Since the Holocaust ended we have said 'Never again'. The world has said that we can't let this happen again, but there have been other genocides. The world is turning its back on the Syrian people, because even though we can see it on our TVs, laptops and smart phones, we still raise our hands and shrug our shoulders in helplessness saying 'but what can we do?' I can assure you that closing our borders, turning back the boats, and locking up would-be Australians on Manus Island and Nauru is not the answer.

We proudly hold up our migrant success stories to show how multicultural we are, but then we deny these potential success stories their own successful migrant narrative by detaining them (as we break many international conventions along the way). The Anzacs didn't fight for our right to live and exclude others from living here too. 

I am in awe of the sacrifices the Anzac soldiers made. I did not understand those sacrifices when I was a student at school as the only Australian history that we were taught was the convict ships, the Eureka stockades, and watching the first half of 'Gallipoli' about four times. I know now that the reality is they were young men, some only boys, who were sent off like 'lambs to the slaughter' to fight for King and Country. The magic of the Anzac spirit is what fuels us. We talk about how they were brave, larrikins, down-to-earth, and above all, looked after one another. Mateship. 

We are not looking after one another right now. By trying to 'protect our values' we are ignoring our principles and our morals. Apparently upon arrival to Australia these days, internationals applying for a visa are made to sign an Australian Values Statement. By signing it, you are saying that you understand:
  • Australian society values respect for the freedom and dignity of the individual, freedom of religion, commitment to the rule of law, Parliamentary democracy, equality of men and women and a spirit of egalitarianism that embraces mutual respect, tolerance, fair play and compassion for those in need and pursuit of the public good
  • Australian society values equality of opportunity for individuals, regardless of their race, religion or ethnic background

That is what the Anzacs fought for. These are the values that make me proud to be Australian. A naturalised Jewish Australian who was born a 3rd generation South African. 
We say 'Never again' and 'Lest we forget' - so let's make them more than just words.



Tuesday, 19 July 2016

That time I got hate mail...

Last week I submitted a Letter to the Editor to The Age that was printed. I wrote a letter in response to Steve Price calling Van Badham hysterical on the ABC program Q&A and at the end of it I kindly (I did say please) asked Price to be quiet as we’ve had enough of his patriarchal and outdated opinions. Apparently I ruffled some feathers.



Today my mother told me there was a letter at their home addressed to me. She said it was handwritten, so I asked her to open it in case it was something urgent. She started reading it over the phone to me and stopped after the first line. “Oh my god,” she said.

Someone had taken the time and effort to literally put pen to paper to tell me what they thought of me. In no uncertain terms, they proceeded to insult me and deride me, finishing the letter by calling me “an overeducated and underworked moron”. Oh, the wonderful irony of calling a high school English teacher underworked.

To cap it off, it was signed “name and address withheld.” The coward, who had the audacity to mail me a letter care of my parents’ address, had declined to assign their name to their taunts.

Badham uploaded a video detailing the types of responses she had received in the wake of her episode on Q&A. Clementine Ford regularly uploads screenshots of the horrific abuse she receives. I’ve just experienced my first (and hopefully last) hate mail and it has left me reeling. Of course, the content of what was in the anonymous letter was ridiculous, and I can tell myself they’re just words; this person clearly knows nothing about me. But it still smarts. I can’t fathom what it would feel like to be on the receiving end of a continuous stream of hate mail like Badham, Ford, and even Sam Frost as she recently bravely revealed.


The irony is that the objective of my Letter to the Editor was to illustrate that in the past women were mute, their thoughts and opinions, moot, and women who dared to speak out or make a fuss were promptly removed from the situation. I have never been one to shy away from sharing my opinion, but this makes me question myself, and that’s not okay. To have the gall to send me a rude and spiteful letter to my parents’ home, and then to be so cowardly as to not sign their name, is an attempt to shame and scare me into silence. Sorry anonymous letter-writer, it’s not going to work.

Sunday, 20 July 2014

"In time, we hate that which we often fear"

It’s rare for me to feel so helpless.

I feel lost and I feel like I don’t understand the world at all anymore. Not that I had a full understanding to begin with, but now…

It started about a month ago with the disappearance of three Israeli teenagers. I hoped for the best, that they would be safely returned, but in my heart of hearts, I knew throughout the #bringbackourboys campaign that they would not be coming back. The international press was more or less silent on the matter, barely rating a mention in the world section of the newspapers.

Then their bodies were found, buried (if you could call it that) in a shallow grave. There was a national outpouring of grief in Israel, the diaspora also in mourning. Still very little media coverage, barely a peep.

A few days later, the body of a young Arab teenager was found in a forest in Jerusalem, his body charred. The press roused from their slumber, stirring. They called it a revenge killing, and sadly, that turned out to be true.

We all know what comes next; rockets from Gaza, targeted air attacks from the IDF. Suddenly, the media – and the world – is up in arms: “How dare Israel do this to the Palestinians?”

Aside from the disproportionate media reporting on the disproportionate death toll as a result of the disproportionate response, there’s a greater, more insidious issue at hand. Under the guise of being pro-Palestinian, there’s been a rise in the number of anti-Semitic demonstrations taking place around the world, in cities such as Paris, Berlin, even in Melbourne. The Jews are not strangers to racism and vilification. But so many people roll their eyes when they hear the word ‘anti-Semitism’. You can practically hear their inner voice saying “oh man, here they go again.” We get called whingers, we get told to get over it, we get told to stop harping on about the Holocaust (like it was no big deal).

Type into Google the words “Israel Palestine” and click on the image results. There are countless political cartoons that I can’t bear to share here, that are reminiscent of the propaganda posters from Nazi Germany. I personally have never been the subject of an anti-Semitic attack, and every time I watch a Holocaust film, I count myself as lucky to have been born in the latter part of the 20th century, and not the earlier part. But why do I now feel so helpless? Why do I now feel so scared?

I went to a Jewish Day School for 13 years. I have been to Israel twice and even lived there for almost a year. I have been to Yad Vashem four times, never mind the innumerable other Holocaust museums and memorials around the world. I am eternally grateful that Israel exists and each year when Yom HaShoah comes around I think to myself, Never Again. But why are there so many people who wish that I didn’t exist? Why are there people who say such awful things like Hitler had the right idea and should have finished us off?

There’s free speech, and then there’s hate speech.

I’m scared because the world doesn’t seem to care that Israel has been bombarded with 1000s of rockets by Hamas, and I’m scared that the world doesn’t seem to realise how they are being manipulated by Hamas, and I’m scared that the world is angry that Israel is defending itself, and I’m scared that the world wouldn’t give a shit if another 6 million Jews were gassed tomorrow.




Thursday, 13 March 2014

"Man is the cruelest animal"

Mahatma Gandhi once said, "When I despair, I remember that all through history the way of truth and love have always won. There have been tyrants and murderers, and for a time, they can seem invincible, but in the end, they always fall. Think of it - always." 

Just over 10 years ago, a 13 year old boy named Daniel Morcombe from the Sunshine Coast in Queensland was kidnapped and then murdered. His parents never gave up hope that justice would be served for their son, and today, that justice was delivered. The man who was convicted of murdering Daniel (he was also convicted of 'interfering' with Daniel and his corpse, which makes me ill just thinking about it) is called Brett Peter Cowan. He is not a first-time offender. Cowan has been twice previously convicted for interfering with a youth under the age of 16 - his previous victims were seven and six years of age (http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/daniel-morcombe-verdict-brett-peter-cowans-criminal-past-20140313-34of4.html ).He served time in jail for both of these crimes. He was released on parole on both occasions.

What I struggle to understand is why do humans treat each other this way? And more to the point; why are monsters like Brett Peter Cowan released back into society after being convicted of such horrific crimes? Cowan has been sentenced to serve a minimum of 20 years in prison before being considered for parole, however, the judge who handed down Cowan's sentence, Justice Roslyn Atkinson, stated, "I am not of the view that you should be released in 20 years' time...that is not in my control."

So who is in control of that decision? The parole board. And sadly, we have seen several incidents in the last few years where the decision of the parole board to release convicted violent offenders early has had tragic consequences. Brett Peter Cowan should NEVER have been released on parole. Adrian Ernest Bayley should NEVER have been released on parole. Why does the parole board keep on making this same mistake? These types of animals are not capable of being rehabilitated. They are recidivists - individuals who will repeat their crimes over and over again.

The silver lining in all this is that Cowan will be in jail for a very long time. He is off the streets and cannot harm another child. I just hope that the parole board throws any application he makes into the bin, and then incinerates it.

Daniel's parents have displayed the utmost bravery and dignity throughout their painful ordeal. They have established a foundation in Daniel's memory which is dedicated to keeping kids safe. For more information please follow this link: http://www.danielmorcombe.com.au/. They have shown that good can triumph over evil, and I hope that they take some comfort in knowing that thanks to their commitment and perseverance, a monster has been removed from society. 


Wednesday, 19 February 2014

Many rivers to cross.

Alright, not so many, just the one named the Howqua River which runs close to the school. 

One of the terms of my new contract at the boarding school included me being a part of the Outdoor Program (OP). It's the basis for the whole school year essentially. Our academic classes run from Thursday to Monday inclusive, but then on Tuesday and Wednesday the girls participate in OP and it's kind of like their weekend. They do fun activities like horse riding, canoeing, mountain bike riding, and learning how to navigate their way around the bush so they can lead the hikes. As the year progresses, these activities become more challenging and physically demanding.

Let it be known that I am a complete novice when it comes to almost all of these activities. Until I got my driver's licence, I didn't know which way was north, and I've been mentally scarred for life since I fell off the bike in the first 100m on Year 8 Outdoor Ed camp and got gravel under the skin of my palm. Yeah.

But one of the greatest regrets I had when I finished up the 2013 school year was that I hadn't been on the hikes with the girls, and hadn't been able to experience the amazing views and activities. I saw my foray into OP as a new challenge, one that I was, more or less, ready to conquer.

Yesterday I embarked on the first real challenge of the Howqua year - the Howqua River Hike. It's the first overnight hike that the girls do, and while it's 'only' an 11km round trip, it's the hardest thing most of these girls have ever had to do. It's the first time they carry their big hike pack which comes to about 15-18kg. Ours as staff weigh closer to the 20kg mark as we have to carry extra gear. There are some steep hills, going both up and down. Going up is harder on the lungs and will get you sweating and puffing, but downhill, ouch. For those of us with less-than-perfect knees, it's tough going downhill, especially when the surface isn't stable. My quads were certainly quivering.

But we made it, with no tears on my part, and only a few tears were shed by one or two of the girls. The camping was fun, the dinner was surprisingly not terrible, and it was such a clear night; once it got dark the stars put on a beautiful show for us.

Day two started off well with a sleep-in and a yum camp breakfast. Just as we were about to head off, there was a clap of thunder and five seconds later it started to rain. We took out our Goretex jackets and some of the looks on the girls' faces - priceless. We started walking and eventually the rain stopped and we were able to take the jackets off. But after we had stopped for lunch next to the river, there was another clap of thunder and a couple of minutes later it started to rain again. But as we were about to trek through the river for about a kilometre, it hardly seemed worth it to put the jackets back on. The water isn't as deep as it was last year, but some parts it still goes over your head, and even closer to the banks of the river, it still comes up to your crotch. So into the river we go, socks and boots and all, and it's raining, and there are girls squealing and slipping, and eventually floating/swimming down the river holding on to their packs as flotation devices.

We made it back to school, soggy socks and squelching hike boots, and after unpacking, cleaning and returning their gear, my colleagues congratulated the girls (and me) on completing our first overnight hike. They said it's something we should be proud of, given what a huge milestone it is in their Howqua year. There were many firsts this trip, some are not fit for sharing in a public forum, but necessary firsts nonetheless! The girls are learning, and so am I. The girls are proud of themselves, and so am I. The girls will sleep well tonight, and so will I.

Sunday, 2 February 2014

Hot and Bothered

After having the Australia Day long weekend off, I drove back up to the boarding school on Australia Day. Since then (a week ago tomorrow), it's been hot, hot, hot. It hasn't been below 37 degrees, and the last few days have been over 40 degrees. It's pretty bloody hot. It's so hot that the packet Haribo gummy bears I bought shmushed together into one big gummy bear mush. It's so hot that any chocolate I had in the pantry completely melted. It's so hot that we've had Zooper Doopers at school every afternoon. It's. Just. So. Hot. The girls arrived on Wednesday morning and to their credit they've probably coped better with the heat than most of the staff. They've honestly been troupers about it. 

Given that I started halfway through the year last year, the girls were pretty used to the fact that they had to run every Friday and Sunday, and by that stage, the fitness runs were up to approximately 9km. Yes, there was whingeing and complaining, but they knew more or less what was expected of them and for the most part, they got on with the run.

Enter the new group of girls. How different things are when you get to see them from the get-go! On Friday they were in good spirits albeit a bit nervous about their first run. They all got through it though, and my favourite quote of the morning was one girl declaring to another, "I'm so sweaty!" You've got to understand that a lot of these girls have never gone running outside before. This is a completely novel experience for most of them. Sweating, that is.

We had the second run this morning which got moved to before breakfast to try and beat the heat. It was lovely actually, getting to run in the cool, fresh morning air before the heat of the day set in. We get assigned running positions so that there's an equal spread of staff throughout the group. I was assigned Tail today which meant that I was the end of the line. Any stragglers get stuck with me prodding them along, shouting words of encouragement, trying to motivate them to keep going, and to stop walking and get running again. This tends to work for me as the girls end up running faster and pulling away, primarily to get away from me I think...hey, motivation comes in all shapes and sizes.  

Part of the challenge, as I mentioned before, is that a lot of these girls may never have exercised before. Sweating is new for them. General pain you get from muscle use is new for them. Stitches are new for them! And that's what I heard today. After a LOT of excuses, the last one right before the final leg of the run was "my side really hurts". She was pinching her waist, bent over, concerned eyebrows. I said "you've just got a stitch". "What's that?" she replied. What's that? What's that! I couldn't believe my ears. Once I explained that it wasn't going to kill her and managed to convince her that she needed to get the oxygen out (not just in), she realised the finish line was not so far away and actually ran the last stretch. They always finish (unless there's an injury), they just need to believe they can do it.

Hard to believe that this same group of girls who are moaning about running a measly 2-3km will be running a 17km run at altitude up and down two peaks by the end of the year. It's what makes their transformation so amazing :)