Saturday, 11 January 2014

Two sides of the same coin.

Ariel Sharon died last night.

Some might argue that technically he died about 8 years ago when he had a severe stroke and was put on life support - he had been in a medically-induced coma since then. At least that was my understanding of the situation. It is my opinion that the man should have been allowed to die with dignity then, but I'm not a doctor, a Rabbi, or his family, so my opinion in this personal matter counts for very little. 

Nelson Mandela died about a month ago now.

It's interesting watching and reading the news reports come out, noting the similarities and differences between the way these two men are memorialised. Mandela and Sharon were both political giants, both fought for what they thought was right, and both made controversial choices in their lives and careers. People marvel at how Mandela was able to forgive his white oppressors while he was imprisoned for nearly 30 years. It is often conveniently forgotten why he was imprisoned in the first place. Before you get too excited, I'm not condoning apartheid, and I'm not suggesting his life sentence was fair. I'm just saying he committed recognised acts of terrorism, and as I mentioned in my earlier blog, Mandela was not a saint. 

Neither was Sharon. Like Mandela, like all of us, he was only human. He was not infallible. God knows, some of his mistakes had disastrous consequences. But he was brave and decisive. His decision to withdraw around 8000 Jewish settlers from Gaza was very unpopular with much of his constituency because it went directly against what his party traditionally stood for - many Israelis still resent him for this. Israel's President Shimon Peres said that Sharon "was one of Israel's great protectors and most important architects, who knew no fear and certainly never feared vision.”

Freedom fighter or terrorist? Military hero or war criminal? I suppose it all depends on which side you're looking at it from.

RIP Ariel Sharon. Long life to your family.



No comments:

Post a Comment